Showing posts with label Woolhandler. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Woolhandler. Show all posts

Monday, April 22, 2019

WILL THE HOSPITALS SHUT DOWN?

NO, THEY WON'T.
Today, I was going to post my thoughts on The Soul of Republicanism, but I changed my mind when I saw Don McCanne's latest post:
When you read it, you'll see that on April 4th of this years, a JAMA article, dated April 4th of this year, supposed that under Single Payer or Medicare For All,  hospitals would suffer grievously. Their income would be markedly reduced due to the lower reimbursement rates currently being paid by Medicare and Medicaid -- rates that hospitals are now able to recoup by charging private patients more -- a strategy which would be unavailable to them under Single Payer. Its conclusion is dire:
In the absence of exceptional public-mindedness among hospital leaders, supporters of Medicare for all should anticipate strong hospital political opposition, especially from leaders who have pursued strategies less focused on efficiency than on extracting ever-increasing payment rates from private payers.

Never particularly friendly to M4A, the New York Times, on April 21st, jumped on the bandwagon with an article whose headline was: Hospitals Stand to Lose Billions Under ‘Medicare for All'. Though the article did close with Dr. Adam Gaffney's assurance that decreased income would be offset by greater efficiencies, that assurance seemed, to this reader at least, not quite able to dispel the gloom of the Times' pessimistic headline.

On April 20th. The Huffington Post observed that hospitals ... alone account for roughly one-third of the nation’s health care spending. No other sector, not even pharmaceuticals, rivals it. Under the Medicare for All proposals from Sanders as well as some other potential reforms getting attention these days, the federal government would limit payments to hospitals, quite possibly reducing their incomes significantly.  Consequently, the hospitals have become part of an industry-wide lobbying effort to defeat any expansion of government-run health insurance, even relatively modest ones that wouldn’t do much to affect their revenue.

To clear the air, Matt Breunig, writing for the People's Policy Project,
points out that in the U.S., 25% of hospital revenue is spent on administrative expenses, whereas hospitals in the Canadian Single Payer system spend only 12% of revenue on administration. What this means, Breunig continues,  is that the administrative efficiencies available under a Medicare for All system allow hospitals to offset 13 points of the 16-point revenue cut without digging into the actual cost of care. The remaining 3 points could come out of hospital profit margin (bringing the margin from 7 percent to 4 percent).

But there's more to it than that. Check out Woolhandler and Himmelstein's

which I present in my post, "Why Is American Healthcare So Expensive: Part Two." There  I discuss their analysis of the high cost of healthcare facilities like hospitals, dialysis centers, etc.  Woolhandler and Himmelstein write:
At present, hospitals’ success, and even survival, depends on generating profits (“surpluses” in non-profit facilities). Hospitals with a favorable bottom line can invest and add new buildings and programs, while unprofitable ones can’t modernize or expand, risking a downward spiral toward takeover or closure....It’s this profit imperative that drives hospitals’ financial gaming, e.g. upcoding, and concentration on the most lucrative services, such as elective cardiac and orthopedic services, rather than money losers like mental health. This payment mechanism ... also leaves the door open to investor-owned providers.

The answer to this, they write, is adopt the strategy used by some European countries, like Scotland, where the hospitals are paid not by procedure, but globally, with one payment intended to cover all  operating expenses. It's the way we in this country pay for firehouses, which, like hospitals, are resources for the public good. And if the firehouse needs to get a new fire engine, the firehouse applies to the municipality that governs it. No government is likely to last if it holds back on improvements the public sees is for its good. It would be the same with our hospitals. They would be expected not to show any profits at all. They could concentrate on their business -- which would not be making money, but healing.

In his discussion of all this, McCanne concludes:
Right now the two major hospital associations are partnering with other members of the medical-industrial complex to publicize [the notion] that hospitals will have to shut down if we enact and implement a single payer Medicare for All program. NOT TRUE! You should be prepared with your response when this comes up:


"Single Payer Medicare for All not only recovers a tremendous amount of administrative waste, but it also uses regional planning, global hospital budgets - like fire departments have - and separate budgeting of capital improvements to ensure that we will always have adequate capacity in our hospital system."

Amen.

The Soul of Republicanism is for our next post.

Dio

PS: If you'd like to leave a comment -- and I encourage you to do so -- simply click on the "number of comments" area, and share your thoughts in the "comment rectangle" that appears.

PPS: We know that there are plenty out there who have stories to tell -- stories of your trying to cope with our dysfunctional healthcare system. Trouble is, we don't know what these stories are! That's where you come in. If you have a story to tell, you can email me at indivisible12401@gmail.com. You can be as anonymous as you like. Thanks!





Friday, January 18, 2019

NOT THE WAY TO CONTROL COSTS

In my post of 12/21/2018 (Why Is American Healthcare Se Expensive -- Part Two), I cited my heroes Woolhandler and Himmelstein, who said, "Medicare's (and other payers') Pay for Performance initiatives impose substantial costs on providers, with no evidence that they've improved patients' outcomes in any setting." [Emphasis added.]

This would seem to conflict with the assertions of those touting what they claim is the success of Medicare’s Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program (HRRP) in lowering risk-adjusted readmission rates for targeted conditions at general acute care hospitals.

But now (in January, 2019) comes a Paper in Health Affairs titled Decreases In Readmissions Credited To Medicare’s Program To Reduce Hospital Readmissions Have Been Overstated. The  Paper's abstract presents a statistical analysis far beyond my sphere of competence. But Don McCanne of the PNHP (Physicians for a National Health Program) comments:  "This study shows that, at a minimum, the benefits of penalizing hospitals for readmitting patients have been tremendously overstated."  Moreover, he points out the additional concern that

patients are often held on observation status rather than being readmitted, sometimes to avoid the readmission penalties. This can significantly increase out-of-pocket costs for the patient since they are billed as outpatients (Part B), with greater cost-sharing, rather than as inpatients (Part A). More importantly, there is also the risk that the patient may receive less care as an outpatient when the patient's condition warrants full inpatient services. Thus the readmission reduction program may be causing significant patient harm, both physically and fiscally.

In conclusion, he states :

The government bureaucrats and the policy community are fixated on these various programs that they just thought up out of the blue that supposedly would control spending, even though their track record overall is dismal. Yet they keep avoiding a proven solution that would reduce our uniquely outrageous administrative waste that costs hundreds of billions of dollars. That solution is a single payer national health program, an improved Medicare that would cover everyone. We should at least enact that and then we could examine other innovations as long as they are designed to truly benefit patients.

Of course he is right:  Single-Payer would save administrative costs more reliably than any of  our government's fiscal schemes, which have proved so far to be, in  McCanne's words, "a dismal failure."  But whether Single-Payer in New York State (NYHA) would control non- administrative costs -- such as hospitals gaming the system in order to make profits, and whether payments to hospitals would reflect current market realities (e.g. regional differences in payscales, etc.) and different standards of excellence (e.g. Memorial Sloan Kettering vs a provincial outfit like Poughkeepsie's Vassar Hospital) has not yet, to my knowledge, been figured out.

The last time I checked, the House of Representatives proposal for Single-Payer adopted Woolhandler and Himmelstein's suggestion that medical facilities such as hospitals should NOT be privately owned and should be compensated NOT by procedure, but should be publicly owned and compensated globally for operating expenses, with capital expenses (MRI machines, etc) awarded by government grants, not by any profits or surpluses, which they would not be supposed to make.  Sanders' Senate Bill keeps the current setup, where hospitals are expected to make profits and are tacitly encouraged to game the system in order to do so. But the House proposal, as I understand it, is currently being rewritten, with results yet to be announced. And how the NYHA would treat these matters is yet to be determined.

With all these uncertainties, why go to single-payer, or for that matter any new system?  The answer is simple: Our current system is fiscally unsustainable and morally bankrupt. Single-Payer seems the best avenue forward. Inaction is not an option. Hence this blog.

Dio

To make a comment, (and we encourage you to do so), simply click on the number of comments area, and share your thoughts in the "comment box" that appears. Thanks!




Saturday, January 5, 2019

MODIFIED RAPTURE!

In Gilbert & Sullivan’s MIKADO, the male romantic lead, Nanki-Poo, is appalled to learn that the girl he loves, Yum-Yum, is to marry someone else.  But when she tells Nanki-Poo than she doesn’t love her fiancĂ©,  her lover exclaims, “modified rapture!”

Just so, when I heard yesterday that Nancy Pelosi supports holding hearings on "Medicare for all," I had an all-too-brief surge of elation.  According to THE HILL, “Pelosi had said last year only that Medicare for all would ‘have to be evaluated’ and is ‘on the table,’” but now...was Pelosi actually saying that the status of Single-Payer had risen from the theoretical to the possible, which the political art might somehow make real? This was worth celebrating, EXCEPT:
  •      Doug Henwood of JACOBIN magazine says that “we have this coalition now developing in Congress of Democrats opposed to any idea of single-payer,  so not obvious at this point.”
  •          We have Democrats in the House who – like Joe Kennedy III – talk a good game about healthcare being a right and not a privilege – but, at the end of the day betray why they may be less than enthusiastic about it.  Kennedy, for example, says he’s concerned that – among other things – it could negatively affect investor - owned hospitals, which include Catholic hospitals in Massachusetts.  He doesn’t mention that he has taken $348,000 in campaign donations from Big Pharma, and that he owns stock in a pharmaceutical company one of whose medications – which fights Hepatitis C – costs $1000 per pill.
  •         Among the ones who say they actually are for some form of “universal healthcare,” there is little agreement as to what form it should take. (See my earlier post “Various Flavors of Healthcare Reform.”)

Meanwhile everyone seems to agree that Single-Payer would save this country money. Even Koch’s Mercatus institute, in an attempt to slam the concept, estimated that in ten years it would cost this country $32 trillion -- which happens to be $2 trillion LESS than what it would cost us if we kept spending at the rate we’re spending now!  And the latest confirmation of the Single-Payer idea – from the Political Economy Research Institute (PERI) -- estimates that, when stabilized, a single-payer plan would save this country 15%-16% of GDP. 

PERI’s report -- Economic Analysis of Medicare for All – was subjected to Peer Reviews, all of which were uniformly positive:
                      Peer Review of PERI Economic Analysis of Medicare for All                    

In their review, my heroes, Woolhandler and Himmelstein, together with the redoubtable Adam Gaffney, pointed out that, based on their own researches,  PERI’s estimates of savings were less than they probably would be, while their estimates of expenses were greater than they probably would be.  In contrast to these conservative estimates,  according to Woolhandler et al,  was the optimism of Peri’s estimate of the time it would take to achieve much savings, if for no other reason than the challenge of reducing to a single computer architecture the daunting welter and variety of systems now being used.

But from my point of view, a very cogent observation was also made by Alison Galvani, who pointed out that while Medicare was pretty good at controlling prices, it wasn’t very good at controlling overuse of high-tech procedures (see my post: Why is American Healthcare So Expensive?).  She pointed out that the same McAllen doctors who, with their Medicare Patients, went through the roof in prescribing procedures that were unlikely to help, were much more conservative when it came to the Blue Cross/Blue Shield patients. He cited an article by Luisa Franzini in Health Affairs, which touted Blue Cross/Blue Shield’s supervisory measures  -- prior approval for elective procedures, and case managers for any case likely to cost $50,000 or more, and so on.  She also mentioned what I felt was one of the most important factors: "Private insurers have the advantage of a “threat point” at which they can ultimately refuse to contract for services to specific physicians or hospitals—something that Medicare cannot do."

I wondered what indeed could rein-in the entrepreneurial ambitions of Doctors.  In outfits like the Mayo Clinic or the Cleveland Clinic, Doctors are on salaries, so that nothing distracts them from focusing on the patient, who comes first.  It turns out that this way, outcomes are better while expenses are less.  Does this mean that Single-payer is going to require all Doctors to be on salaries? I wouldn’t hold your breath waiting.

But there is one economy that Galvani doesn’t mention:  As Woolhandler, Himmelstein, and Gaffney point out, that PERI analysis uses the House version’s approach to Hospitals, Clinics, Dialysis Centers:  the gradual take-over of all such privately owned facilities so that ultimately they are publicly owned,  (no stockholders) and directed NOT to make a profit.  The profit incentive being removed, these facilities are no longer incentivized to game the system and are supported globally, the way we support firehouses.  It’s a great idea, though Joe Kennedy III isn’t likely to be pleased with it.

The action in congress is thus likely to be fascinating and extremely consequential.  But that doesn’t mean we should ease up on our own efforts. Don McCanne,  a physician who writes a blog for the Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP), writes the following:

“The hearings will be part of the process, but it is important that we continue with our other advocacy activities as well. Special targets should include politicians who do not yet seem to understand why single payer is an imperative, and politicians who profess to be advocates but who could be swayed to support detrimental reform policies in a perversion of the process of political compromise. We need to continue to work with politicians who are already fully on board, but we should also continue our efforts to educate those who say they are opposed, if,  for no other reason, they might accept defeat more readily were they to understand the clear social benefit of Medicare for All.  Also we cannot let up in the least in our efforts to educate the public at large. Grassroots efforts will continue to be an essential component of the reform effort.”  (Emphasis added)

This paragraph contains marching orders for all of us.  As the discussions intensify, both in Albany and D.C., our efforts must likewise grow stronger and more passionate.   On the day when Single-Payer passes in New York State, we all will experience not modified, but complete rapture!










WHO ARE YOU TRYING TO FOOL, NANCY? Will the April 30 Hearing on Medicare For All Be Little More Than a Farce? That may well be the case...