Showing posts with label Dialysis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dialysis. Show all posts

Monday, December 24, 2018

WHY IS AMERICAN HEALTHCARE SO EXPENSIVE?

Part Two
In this blog’s early posts, we saw how Big Pharma exploits its near monopolistic powers by raising prices simply because it can, resulting in the shortened lives of many patients who have been priced out of living.

In the current two-part series, the first part showed the results of Physicians and other providers gaming the system by ordering unnecessary procedures – which benefits mainly them, unlike Patient Centered systems like the Mayo Clinic, where their salaried doctors have no incentive to drive up charges, and everything is focused on institution-wide teamwork in healing the patient.  The former is profit-driven, the latter patient-driven, resulting in better outcomes at lower costs.

So far, if we’ve been paying attention, we’d be justified in concluding that where patient care is concerned, considerations of profit are poison.

But what about Hospitals and Clinics, Dialysis Centers and the like? Are considerations of profit poison for them as well? The answer is a resounding YES, according to Steffie Woolhandler and David Himmelstein, the pre-eminent Physicians/Scholars, co-founders of the Physicians for a National Health Program,  the lead authors of the PNHP’s healthcare reform article published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, which in turn is the basis of H.R. 676 , the Single-Payer Bill from the House of Representatives. Woolhandler and Himmelstein are, in my opinion, the God-Parents of our movement. and are worth listening to.

They spell out their position in the article: IMPORTANCE OF ALIGNING HOUSE AND SENATE SINGLE-PAYER BILLS THE RIGHT WAY: Removing Medicare’s Profiteering Incentive is Key. I encourage you to read it:

Woolhandler and Himmelstein say that the Senate Bill, unlike the House Bill “...would, like Medicare, pay hospitals and other institutional providers on a per-patient basis, intermixing payments for current operating expenses with funding for future capital investments and profits. At present, hospitals’ success, and even survival, depends on generating profits (“surpluses” in non-profit facilities). Hospitals with a favorable bottom line can invest and add new buildings and programs, while unprofitable ones can’t modernize or expand, risking a downward spiral toward takeover or closure....It’s this profit imperative that drives hospitals’ financial gaming, e.g. upcoding, and concentration on the most lucrative services, such as elective cardiac and orthopedic services, rather than money losers like mental health. This payment mechanism (and S.1804 as a whole) also leaves the door open to investor-owned providers.”

The authors go on to explain why payment for performance schemes – in addition to requiring expensive bureaucratic overhead – provide “no evidence that they’ve improved patients’ outcomes in any setting.” Moreover – it should go without saying – the minute you have an investor-owned enterprise, you must compromise quality to ensure profits. Privately owned dialysis centers, for example, have far worse outcomes than community owned ones.

Contrast all this with the model provided by Scotland and several other European countries who pay these institutions the way we pay firehouses – globally – to take care of operating expenses. Our firehouses aren’t expected to make a “profit” to save for a new firetruck.  If they need one, they appeal to the local municipality to buy them one.

The House’s H.R. 676, similarly, would pay medical institutions globally, covering all operating costs, and would allow no “profits.” If new equipment or expansions are warranted, they would get them from the government, which – if it wanted to stay in office – would provide them promptly. And privately owned facilities would be made publicly owned by the government’s buying them out. This would be less expensive than  it might at first appear, partly because health facilities typically carry a debt load, and partly because it would not be done all at once, but over a period of time.

Everyone agrees that once established, Single-Payer would save money if for no other reason than obscene profits and bloated bureaucratic overhead would be eliminated (contrast Medicare’s 2% overhead with conventional insurance’s 12%).  While that is not small potatoes, it might well not be enough to meaningfully lighten the burden of healthcare on our economy.  As our authors point out:
“In sum, the financial viability of a single-payer reform turns on cutting administrative costs and minimizing incentives for financial gaming. Maintaining Medicare’s current payment strategies, as under S.1804, would be substantially costlier than adopting the non-profit global-budgeting strategy used in several other nations.”

Atul Gawande, physician/author of the article on which the previous post is based, is more blunt:
“When it comes to making care better and cheaper, changing who pays the doctor will make no more difference than changing who pays the electrician. The lesson of the high-quality, low-cost communities is that someone has to be accountable for the totality of care. Otherwise, you get a system that has no brakes. You get McAllen.”

To me this means that setting up Single-Payer – by itself – will not be enough, unless it removes the profit motive, regulates  greed, minimizes the incentives to game the system, and unless it requires healthcare providers to meet carefully fashioned public standards . If this happens, the cost savings and improvements in care will be very great.

There will be plenty of arguments, pro and con, for everything that’s been said in all my posts. Our job is to stay on top of them, making sure that when reform is done, it’s done right.

Dio

PS: To leave a comment (and I encourage you to do  so) just click on the number of comments area, and share your thoughts in the “comment box” that appears.






Thursday, November 29, 2018

RATIONING

I have spoken, on these pages, about the delivery of  Healthcare only to those who can afford it. In a land of such abundance as ours, this rationing is unconscionable. For a stark example, we need look no further than a heart clinic's recent letter to a woman seeking a heart transplant:

"Your medical situation was presented to our multidisciplinary heart transplant committee on Tuesday, October 20, 2018. The decision made by this committee is that you are not a candidate at this time for a heart transplant due to needing a more secure financial plan for immunosuppressive medication coverage. The committee is recommending a fundraising effort of  $10,000....We thank you for the opportunity to participate in your care." 

WTF?! 

This woman has been told to beg for $10K from GoFundMe, a crowd source where, I'm told,  one of three appeals is based on healthcare needs. and this in the United States where the plutocrats have more money than they know what to do with, and yet the leading cause of bankruptcy is healthcare bills.  Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is dead-on to decry GoFundMe as official policy: "Customers can die if they can't raise the goal in time - but sure, single-payer healthcare is unreasonable." 

Her sarcasm stems from her knowledge that Single payer is in fact the only reasonable healthcare proposal out there. It's based on the premise that there can be plenty of healthcare resources for all -- plenty of medicines, plenty of healthcare providers, and plenty of  money to pay them. Plenty, I say, with one big seemingly intractable exception:  organs for transplant. There are far more patients needing them than there are organs available, and that situation is not likely to change any time soon.

I have a personal interest in this, having inherited a kidney disorder which can lead to renal failure and dialysis, which could shorten my life substantially. By the grace of God, so far I am holding my own in this. Yet should I ultimately need dialysis, I'm sure I'd be better off in many other medical systems than the one under which we currently suffer.  

Eight years ago, there appeared in THE ATLANTIC MONTHLY  an article which shook me up. It was called God Help You. You're on Dialysis. It began as follows:

Every year, more than 100,000 Americans start dialysis. One in four of them will die within 12 months—a fatality rate that is one of the worst in the industrialized world. Oh, and dialysis arguably costs more here than anywhere else. Although taxpayers cover most of the bill, the government has kept confidential clinic data that could help patients make better decisions. How did our first foray into near-universal coverage, begun four decades ago with such great hope, turn out this way? And what lessons does it hold for the future of health-care reform?

It goes on to detail how our dialysis programs are set up for corporate profit, at the expense of patient health, and contrasts it unfavorably with what it calls The Italian Solution, and singles out a town called Reggio Calabria,  dusty and poor, and whose hospital "has the tired grubbiness of a bus station," but whose unit for kidney patients is "world-beating," and concludes:

Other countries provide universal access to dialysis care, much like the United States. But some, notably Italy, have better patient survival and cost control. Italy has one of the lowest mortality rates for dialysis care—about one in nine patients dies each year, compared with one in five here. Yet Italy spends about one-third less than we do per patient.

It's really a terrific article -- though 8 years old, it's more timely than ever!
I recommend it heartily. Here's the link: God Help You. You're on Dialysis   After I read it I figured that if worst came to worst, I'd learn Italian!

But if we should get Single payer health care by that time, I wouldn't have to move abroad.  I might have to reconcile myself to the fact that a younger man with his life ahead of him would more likely to be allotted  a scarce kidney than would an 82-year-old like me. But I wouldn't have to shudder -- as I do now -- that the corporate blood-sucking ghoul of greed  would be stalking our hospital halls,  lurking in corners of our clinics, and standing drooling over the surgeon's shoulder as he cuts open a patient's chest to replace his heart.

Dio

I welcome comments, which you can enter by clicking on the number of comments area. Don't be afraid to teach me something -- I'm learning all the time!





WHO ARE YOU TRYING TO FOOL, NANCY? Will the April 30 Hearing on Medicare For All Be Little More Than a Farce? That may well be the case...