Showing posts with label New York Times. Show all posts
Showing posts with label New York Times. Show all posts

Saturday, March 23, 2019

PAUL KRUGMAN VS. WHO?


Anyone who has read the New York Times will likely recognize the gentleman on the right: He's Paul Krugman, Nobel Prize winning Economist and Columnist for the Times. It would be hard to be more distinguished than he. 

I'd be surprised if many of my readers recognized the gentleman in the left: He's Don McCanne, MD, who in addition to being a physician, has been all his life a student of health policy.  He currently serves as Chief Policy Fellow for the Physicians for a National Health Plan PHNP), a body in which he served as President in 2002 and 2003. There is no more passionate advocate for Single-Payer than Dr. McCanne, and I read his daily blog with the deepest respect.  

On Sunday, March 17, the Texas Tribune published Patrick Sviteck's story about Beto O'Rourke's pivoting on his healthcare plan preference:
Sviteck explains that O'Rourke, never more than luke-warm towards the notion of Single-Payer, seemed more comfortable embracing a policy considerably to the right of  it -- Medicare for America.  Sviteck quotes him:

"It responds to the fact that so many Americans have said, ‘I like my employer-based insurance. I want to keep it. I like the network I’m in. I like the doctor that I see,'" O'Rourke said. "It complements what already exists with the need that we have for millions of Americans who do not have insurance and ensures that each of them can enroll in Medicare. It then suggests additional investments in that program so it becomes the program of choice, and people who have private insurance migrate over to the Medicare system."
Someone questioned him:"So the greed has to stay in the insurance industry in your opinion?"
Beto paused, then said that he didn't see it as a function of greed. "I think I have to be respectful to people who just shared with me what I shared with you: They like the program they’re in, they like the insurance that they have," O'Rourke said. "If we become too ideological or too prescribed in the solution, we may allow the perfect to become the enemy of the good. And there are fellow American human lives depending on us finding a solution."

Upon reading this,  Dr. McCanne posted a very passionate statement about 
He says that virtually nobody in this country does. "The obvious point" he writes, "is that people do not have stable health care coverage throughout their lives." And as he makes clear, there are too many reasons why the insurance companies change, or their policies do, or the networks do.  I suggest you read his article I've linked above: I never knew there were so many reasons why the insurance you have can and will change, but I can testify that in my lifetime that has been my experience.  

And as for that shibboleth "freedom of choice," you have to go along with whatever your employer chooses to give you -- if he chooses anything. You get the doctors and the network that your employer chooses. But as McCanne says, with Single-Payer, you don't have to worry about doctors being in your network; You can choose any doctor, any hospital you want: they're all in the same network!  (This would be very much unlike Medicare for America, if it devolves into a two-tiered system -- one more pricey than the other -- those who belong to the medicare tier might find themselves priced out of the tier whose pricier doctors might not want to treat them. That sort of thing is happening as I write this. There is a physician in Kingston, well thought of,  whose receptionist told me: "Of course Doctor doesn't take Medicare. That's what you have? You should have told me from the get-go, and not wasted my time!" Luckily for Carol and me, we could find quite a few other good doctors in Kingston who do take Medicare.)

Thus this argument for Medicare for America -- that you can keep the insurance you have -- is, in McCanne's opinion, based upon a fallacy. And, as I said in my most recent post, Medicare for America, in my opinion, would be unlikely to last long, if for no other reason that no billion dollar company is going to sit quietly by while it is being put out of business -- however slowly. They'll deploy every dollar they have to lie, distort, and bribe.

Despite all this, Paul Krugman believes that eventually most of the Democratic candidates will be persuaded to move rightward and and embrace Medicare for America. In  his recent opinion piece,
Krugman asks, 
But even if optimistic claims about Medicare for All are true, will people believe them? And even if most people do, if a significant minority of voters doesn’t trust the promises of single-payer advocates, that could easily either doom Democrats in the general election or at least make it impossible to get their plan through Congress.
And he points out that -- just as there is more than one way to skin a cat -- there are in the world many ways proven successful in providing universal healthcare. "Every two years," he says,  "the Commonwealth Fund provides an invaluable survey of major nations’ health care systems. America always comes in last; in the latest edition, the three leaders are Britain, Australia and the Netherlands. 

"What’s remarkable about those top three is that they have radically different systems. Britain has true socialized medicine — direct government provision of health care. Australia has single-payer — it’s basically Bernie down under. But the Dutch rely on private insurance companies — heavily regulated, with lots of subsidies, but looking more like a better-funded version of Obamacare than like Medicare for All. And the Netherlands actually tops the Commonwealth Fund rankings."

Krugman then asks,  "So which system should Democrats advocate? The answer, I’d argue, is the system we’re most likely actually to create — the one that will play best in the general election, and is then most likely to pass Congress if the Democrat wins." 

He concludes, "To me, then, Medicare for America — which lets people keep employment-based insurance — looks like a much better bet for actually getting universal coverage than Medicare for All. But I could be wrong! And it’s fine to spend the next few months arguing the issue. What won’t be fine will be if activists make a no-private-insurance position a litmus test, declaring that anyone advocating a more incrementalist approach is no true progressive, or maybe a corrupt shill for the medical/industrial complex. As you might guess, my concerns aren’t drawn out of thin air; they’re things I’m already hearing."

So the next few months will be anything but boring! And the thing is: I'm really not 100% sure of where I am on all this.  In the readers comments section -- which I strongly urge you to read -- readers give their views about Krugman's opinions. In the first New York Times Pick, you can read:
"Private insurance is mostly there to say No, you can’t have that, but if you do, we’re not going to pay for it. And we currently pay through the nose for these companies to tell us that. Who in their right mind is “satisfied” w that? Only stupid people or people w ties to the health insurance industry. No, private health insurance, w the possible exception of “boutique” brands for the wealthy, should be abolished. I don’t often disagree w Mr. Krugman, but this time I do. Wholeheartedly. Is my view impractical? Let’s forget the polls and vote on it."

After reading this, I thought, "yes, yes! Those !*#@*! [the healthcare companies] should not be rewarded for what they've put us through! I agree 100 percent! But then I read:

"One of the problems that Progressives will have in selling Medicare for All is that they have made a compelling case for the utter corruptibility of politicians due to money in politics. The GOP over the years has made a much less honest but electorial effective case that "liberal elites" cannot be trusted. And Trump has demonstrated the weaknesses in oversight, check and balances, and the value of facts in our system of government in the face of extreme partisanship and the conservative media ecosystem. "So how do you convince the rightfully skeptical, currently insured but potentially persuadable, to let OUR Federal government take this much control over health care NOW? "Explaining all the positives of Medicare for All is easy relative to the challenge of explaining how THIS government, that will without question still be highly partisan in 2020 and still awash in big donor money, is capable of pulling this off. "Have a robust debate. If Medicare for All resonates with a solid majority of voters across a majority of states that's great. I hope it goes that way. "But if not, keep in mind that our democracy may not survive another 4 years of Trump and McConnell. Medicare for All is not the hill to die on. [Emphasis added]

After reading this, I think, OMG, of course, of course! This makes sense!

Let our good doctor, the esteemed Don McCanne -- only one year younger than I -- have the last word about what we activists for Single-Payer must bear in mind:

This is a time for PASSION. We have to get this message out there.

As with everything else, he is so right about this, too.

Dio

PS: If you'd like to leave a comment -- and I encourage you to do so -- simply click on the "number of comments" area, and share your thoughts in the "comment rectangle" that appears.

PPS: We know that there are plenty out there who have stories to tell -- stories of your trying to cope with our dysfunctional healthcare system. Trouble is, we don't know what these stories are! That's where you come in. If you have a story to tell, you can email me at indivisible12401@gmail.com. You can be as anonymous as you like. Thanks!


















Wednesday, February 6, 2019

THE NEW YORK TIMES IS 

NOT ALWAYS GOSPEL

On February 2nd, Jonathan Martin and Amy Goodnough in the New York Times wrote an article that unsettled me. I provide a link to it below:
Medicare For All Emerges as Early Policy Test
Prior to reading it, I had managed to feel that somehow there might be hope in our country's finally adopting a genuine single-payer program. But the article left me feeling that there was no way our elected Democrat representatives would spring for it -- or anything like it. But then I read an email circulated by Maggie Veve, an activist in the New Paltz area. What she said made so much sense that, with her permission, I'm reprinting it here:

This is a conventional article, not a good one: it's misleading (cost) and therefore, biased. In addition, the content is expected. 

 I am sure you know that politicians test the waters and politicians run scared. They run scared with the Green New Deal (GND) too. We will see the same when the fuel industry really hits back hard against the GND. It's just easier to run from Medicare for All because the fight is on with heavy hitters of the for-profit health establishment. They know health care cost is a non-partisan issue and that hearings will occur in the House. So the industry is clearly afraid of losing profits and wants to scare the populace with "socialism", "bankrupting the economy", "no choice", "long waits" to distract from the radical / root causes of the true cost of the current system. We cannot afford NOT to do what every other developed nation provides for their citizens. I think we need to educate the populace and push for what we think is right ("imagine the best of what is possible"/Deray McKesson). I also believe the narrative can be turned around by fearless belief in the right thing to do.

For an example of this fearless belief in the right thing to do, Maggie  provides a link featuring AOC answering Chris Cuomo's challenge: "How are you going to pay for all this healthcare, this Green New Deal you want?" AOC answers him with words that are for the ages:
Not satisfied with that, Maggie then forwards her letter to Elissa Krauss, in these parts the lead organizer and advocate for the NYHA and Single-Payer in general. And Ms. Krauss replies with an email that nails it:

Thanks for including me in the conversation. Some thoughts:
   1.The regular Dems oppose Medicare for All. The Dem Congressional Campaign Committee specifically forbade candidates from mentioning single payer. Antonio Delgado has made clear that he does NOT favor Medicare for All. He wants a public option. More on that later.
  2. It is true that the Mercatus Center projected cost of Medicare for $32 trillion WITH A SAVINGS OF $2 trillion over 10 years. In other words, even a right wing think tank had to acknowledge that Medicare for All would cost LESS than current costs for health care. 
  3. NYHA would save New Yorkers billions in health care costs. Instead of premiums, deductibles and co-pays New Yorkers would pay a progressive tax on payroll and non-payroll income, that tax can be less than what they are currently paying.
  4. Two studies agree that NYHA would save money for New York and for New Yorkers. The RAND study agrees that single payer would cost NY less than current costs. It mistakenly predicts that some low-income New Yorkers would pay more for health care than they do now.  That’s because RAND’s analysis is based on a hypothetical tax structure that is not truly progressive and assumes that all New Yorkers would have to pay a tax. The Friedman study presumes that no tax would be paid on incomes less than $25,000.
   5. Exactly how the NYHA tax would be calculated remains to be seen.  First the bill needs to pass. Then the very important details need to be worked out. But the bill specifies a progressive tax. Remember- current private health insurance is a regressive tax. Note – NYHA is improved Medicare for All. No premiums, deductibles or co-pays,
   6. For single payer advocates I think the message of this article has to be – we have to embrace taxes as a cost-effective way to provide care to all. The fiction that all taxes are bad has been promulgated by opponents of government who have taken over the national government at the same time as they are trying to dismantle it. We need taxes. Taxes pay for police, firefighters, roads, bridges, and schools among other things. These important basics of society are all suffering because of the successful myth that taxes are inherently bad. Remember in Europe those higher taxes pay for free public education from Pre-K through college, access to medical care for all, paid family leave, longer vacations, etc.
   7. Public option. PNHP [Physicians for a National Health Plan] opposes a public option for the simple reason that if private insurance companies were competing against the government then we would see an expansion of what we are seeing now. The government provides care for the sickest, oldest and poorest. With a public option private companies could go further in limiting who they would cover and focus on the younger, healthier and richer. We would end up with an even worse two-tier system than we have now.
      So those are some thoughts on the NYT opinion piece. It is true that some studies show that when people are told that Medicare for All would increase taxes or end their private insurance, some get scared. BUT those questions do not tell them that their costs would be lower and their access to care increased.
      Let’s continue this conversation. Henry Moss is better than I am at covering these issues. I’m sure he’d be glad to come back to New Paltz to do another presentation.

Elissa

Personally, I don't believe that anybody could be much better in covering these issues than Elissa.

What  more can I say? After 57 years of marriage, I've learned to listen to women smarter than I am.

Hurray for Maggie!
Hurray for Elissa!
Hurray for AOC!

With women like these -- and thank God there are plenty of 'em -- we're in good shape!

Dio

PS: If you want to leave a comment -- and I hope you will -- simply click on the number of comments area and share your thoughts in the "comment rectangle" that appears.
PPS: If you'd like to share your story, I'd like to help you. You can share it publicly -- if you're up to it -- or privately, with only your representative knowing it. Either way, you would be helping the cause. Our current medical system is hurting people.  If you are one of them, you deserve to be heard. You need to be heard.  Thanks!

WHO ARE YOU TRYING TO FOOL, NANCY? Will the April 30 Hearing on Medicare For All Be Little More Than a Farce? That may well be the case...